Kevin Coleman's Dynasty/Devy Mailbag
Kevin answers mailbag questions from our subscribers fro the month of December.
Hey everyone! I’m excited to kick off this month’s Mailbag article, where I tackle your burning questions about fantasy football, devy leagues, and everything in between. Whether you’re looking for trade advice, player breakdowns, or strategy tips, this is the place where we break it all down together.
This feature will be dropping once a month, so keep an eye out for me asking for your questions on Discord or social media. Have something on your mind now? Feel free to drop a question in the comments below, and I’ll do my best to include it next time.
Let’s dive in and see what you’ve got for me this month!
With top-tier RB production this year and the decline in WR production compared to last year. Do you feel there might be a shift in RB valuation with the crop of 2025 RBs coming in? Is 2025 the year of WR valuation reckoning? @SilverSurfie
Yes, and here's why: We're witnessing a resurgence in running back production across the board, and this trend could signal a shift in dynasty valuations. The NFL's current crop of running backs is aging out, creating a vacuum for new talent. Also, we are seeing aging running backs continue to produce meaningful numbers, making the position more valuable even as the position gets older. Enter the 2025 running back class, which, as it stands (without declarations finalized), is shaping up to be one of the deepest we've seen in recent memory.
Jay Stein and I will break this class down in greater detail on Monday in our upcoming video, but here’s a sneak peek:
This group has the potential to redefine rookie drafts, especially given the disappointing performance of the 2024 running back class. Combine that with the current oversaturation of wide receivers in dynasty leagues, and it’s clear why running backs might take center stage.
Dynasty teams are starved for reliable RB production, and I anticipate a significant uptick in running backs being prioritized in rookie drafts over wide receivers. The 2025 draft could very well mark a turning point in how dynasty managers approach roster construction.
Thoughts on Jaylen Warren's future value with The Steelers declining Harris's 5th-year option. @keegannotvegan
Jaylen Warren hasn’t been a standout in terms of production, but his efficiency metrics do tell a different story. Since Week 7, he’s been the RB34 in fantasy points per game, averaging 11.4 touches and 62.1 total yards per contest. Despite limited playing time, Warren ranks ninth in missed tackles forced per attempt and 13th in yards after contact per attempt among 41 qualifying running backs over that stretch. He’s shown flashes of explosiveness, but Pittsburgh’s commitment to Najee Harris has kept him from seeing a more significant workload.
Looking ahead, the Steelers declining Harris’s fifth-year option is noteworthy. While it’s unlikely Harris returns in 2025, Warren’s role should be viewed with cautious optimism. He’s 26 years old and hasn’t consistently performed as an RB1 in fantasy, with only four top-12 PPR finishes across his three-year career. Even if Harris departs, Pittsburgh’s offensive system under OC Arthur Smith doesn’t favor a single back dominating touches.
Additionally, the 2025 draft class is loaded with running back talent, making it probable the Steelers add competition to their backfield. My recommendation? Use the offseason hype surrounding Warren as a selling point. With Harris likely out, his perceived value will spike, making it the perfect time to capitalize before the Steelers bring in fresh talent.
Who are the best college football hires this off-season? @Kegger
Bill Belichick – North Carolina
The biggest hire of the offseason, period. Bill Belichick’s move to North Carolina is groundbreaking—not just for college football, but for sports as a whole. It’s a hire on par with Deion Sanders’ arrival at Colorado two years ago, though arguably even bigger considering Belichick’s résumé includes six Super Bowl rings. The question is whether his legendary coaching acumen and meticulous approach will translate to the college game, which is shifting closer to a semi-pro structure with NIL collectives and NFL-style front offices.
Belichick brings immediate credibility and a $20 million NIL war chest to attract top-tier talent, complemented by a handpicked staff of NFL-caliber personnel. The foundation for success is in place; now, it's about execution.
Bronco Mendenhall – Utah State
Bronco Mendenhall returns to his home state of Utah with one goal: rebuilding the Utah State program. After successful stints at BYU (99-43, two Mountain West titles) and Virginia, Mendenhall took a brief hiatus before resurfacing at New Mexico in 2024, where he led the Lobos to a respectable 5-7 record.
Utah State, coming off a tumultuous season that included the firing of Blake Anderson due to compliance issues, is betting on Mendenhall’s steady leadership to bring stability and success. His track record speaks for itself—this is a hire that could quietly become one of the best of the cycle.
Zach Kittley – FAU
At just 33 years old, Zach Kittley becomes the youngest head coach in FBS, taking over at FAU. Known for his Air Raid expertise, Kittley has been a rising star, making waves at Texas Tech, Western Kentucky, and Houston Christian (formerly Houston Baptist). His offenses consistently rank among the nation’s best, and now he brings that dynamic style to the Sunshine State—a major selling point for recruits.
FAU’s hire shows their commitment to innovation and offensive firepower. Kittley’s track record includes producing elite passing offenses and developing players like Bailey Zappe, who set NCAA records under his guidance. Expect FAU to light up scoreboards in the coming years.
Ben Arbuckle – Oklahoma (Offensive Coordinator)
Oklahoma’s hire of Ben Arbuckle as offensive coordinator signals a significant shift in offensive philosophy. Arbuckle, who engineered one of the most explosive offenses in the country at Washington State, reunites with quarterback John Mateer in Norman.
Arbuckle’s offenses at Washington State were nothing short of prolific, ranking among the best nationally in passing efficiency, touchdowns, and total offense. His ability to develop quarterbacks and maximize offensive potential will be key as Oklahoma transitions to a more competitive SEC landscape.
Are there any RBs in this class that are landing spot-proof? @Halllerjono21
Right now, only two running backs in this class fit the description: Boise State’s Ashton Jeanty and UNC’s Omarion Hampton.
A true junior, Jeanty has been nothing short of phenomenal, amassing 4,665 career rushing yards at an impressive 6.5 yards per carry (not including the CFB playoff). To put that in perspective, this season alone, he’s averaging 7.3 yards per carry and leads the nation in yards after contact—more than any player Pro Football Focus (PFF) has ever recorded. His versatility in the receiving game is equally impressive, with 43 catches as a sophomore and 20 so far this year.
Jeanty isn’t just a numbers guy—his film is equally spectacular. With a complete three-down skill set, elite vision, and the ability to make defenders miss in tight spaces, he transforms an average ground game into a legitimate threat.
His 2024 stats are staggering: 2,497 rushing yards (fourth all-time in a single FBS season), 29 rushing touchdowns (tied for first nationally), and a country-leading 2,613 all-purpose yards. With 121 first downs and 180 total points scored, Jeanty is a game-changer. He’s even closing in on Barry Sanders’ legendary single-season rushing record, needing just 132 yards in the Fiesta Bowl to surpass it. Jeanty will simply fit any system he is drafted in.
Hampton brings a powerful yet decisive running style to the table. He’s not one to seek out contact, but when it’s unavoidable, he meets defenders with force, often shedding would-be tacklers with ease. His north-south approach prioritizes getting upfield quickly rather than wasting motion with lateral movement.
Hampton broke out as a sophomore, forming a dynamic duo with quarterback Drake Maye to propel UNC’s offense. That year, he tallied 1,504 rushing yards (second-most in UNC history) and 15 touchdowns. His 1,072 yards after contact led the nation, showing just how difficult he is to bring down.
In 2024, Hampton raised the bar even higher. He rushed for 1,660 yards, second in the country behind just Jeanty, and added 15 more touchdowns, setting a UNC record with 2,033 all-purpose yards. For his efforts, Hampton earned first-team All-ACC honors and became a two-time finalist for the Doak Walker Award. With back-to-back 1,500+ yard seasons, he joins elite ACC company, including Dalvin Cook, Travis Etienne, and Lamar Jackson—names synonymous with NFL success.
Both Jeanty and Hampton possess the rare combination of talent, production, and versatility to succeed in any NFL system. Regardless of where they land, their skill sets make them standout prospects who should thrive at the next level.
Based on the question above: Who could be a potential bust who is ranked high when they get drafted by the wrong team? (It could be lack of talent and land in a shitty team, or a stud in front of the depth chart) @Gerrit-Jan
Early in the offseason, one player who stands out as a potential bust if he lands in the wrong situation is Kaleb Johnson. While Johnson has a lot going for him, there are noticeable concerns about his ability to break away in the open field. He shows good acceleration through the line of scrimmage, but when it comes to hitting space or reaching the edge, defensive backs consistently close on his angles. Instead of outrunning them, he often has to rely on downfield moves to create opportunities, which limits his explosive potential.
That being said, Johnson’s inside running is solid. He’s capable of converting big gains when attacking between the tackles, but without an extra gear to separate, his ceiling feels limited in offenses that rely on breakaway speed.
The only scenario where I’d feel confident in Johnson is if he’s drafted by a team with a wide-zone rushing scheme. In this type of system, his combination of size, physicality, vision, and ability to press runs and cut off defensive flow could shine. Offenses rooted in the Shanahan coaching tree, for instance, might be an ideal fit for his skill set.
Even then, the concern is that he might end up being drafted too high, setting lofty expectations that may not align with his capabilities outside of a very specific scheme. While there’s potential for success, a poor fit could see Johnson struggle to live up to his draft-day value.
What the hell do I do with Jaylen Waddle and Brandon Aiyuk? @Jdp227
I’m selling both of these assets, but timing is key. Let’s start with Brandon Aiyuk. For him, I’m holding until the middle of the offseason—especially if San Francisco moves on from Deebo Samuel. Aiyuk was the talk of the offseason after a career-best 2023 campaign where he racked up 75 catches for 1,342 yards and seven touchdowns. However, his quest for a contract extension created a lot of uncertainty. The 49ers even explored trading him to Pittsburgh before ultimately signing him to a four-year, $120 million deal.
Unfortunately, his 2024 season was far from what dynasty managers hoped for. Aiyuk only managed 25 catches for 374 yards with no touchdowns in seven games before suffering a devastating ACL and MCL tear. While it’s been an up-and-down season, the context matters—his offseason limbo likely impacted his focus and production early on.
Aiyuk’s dynasty value has been all over the place. He surged into the top 20 WR rankings late last year, only to fall into the 40s before his injury. Now, his value is likely to dip even further into the 50s or 60s, making a "sell high" move impossible. If you’re rebuilding, now might be a good time to buy low on Aiyuk for a veteran running back. Otherwise, hold until we get clarity on Deebo’s situation or Aiyuk shines again in training camp.
Example Dynasty Trades (12 Team SF/TE Premium):
Brandon Aiyuk for Derrick Henry
Brandon Aiyuk/Drake Maye for Brock Bowers/2025 1st
Brandon Aiyuk for Jonnu Smith/Rashod Bateman
Brandon Aiyuk for James Conner/2025 3rd
Brandon Aiyuk/2025 2nd for Tyreek Hill
Now, let’s move to Jaylen Waddle. I’m ready to pivot off him entirely. Waddle’s talent is undeniable, and he plays in a pass-friendly system, but his constant injuries make him a long-term liability. If you can tier up to someone like Drake London or land a package that includes Xavier Worthy, those are deals I’d jump on. It’s time to move on while his name still holds weight in trade discussions.
Example Dynasty Trades (12 Team SF/TE Premium):
Jaylen Waddle for Jonnu Smith/2025 2nd
Jaylen Waddle for Mike Evans
Jaylen Waddle for 2025 1st
Jaylen Waddle/Courtland Sutton for Drake London
Jaylen Waddle for Derrick Henry
Who is your 1.01 in SF rookie drafts right now? @ThePPRShow
At this stage of the 2025 draft class evaluation, a clear tier break exists after the first two picks. The top prospects, Arizona WR Tetairoa McMillan and Boise State RB Ashton Jeanty, have separated themselves from the pack, and it’s not particularly close. Now, there will be an argument about who should be 1.01 in drafts, and here’s how I think that plays out, along with some quick player profiles.
Tetairoa McMillan - 6’5”, 215 LBS (WR, Arizona)
McMillan has cemented his place as a top-tier prospect, showcasing an incredible collegiate career. He recently surpassed Bobby Wade as Arizona’s all-time receiving yards leader, amassing 3,365 yards and 25 touchdowns over three seasons. This year alone, he’s tallied 84 receptions for 1,319 yards and 8 touchdowns, despite playing on an underwhelming team. Highlights like his 304-yard, 4-TD game against New Mexico solidify his potential to be a top-10 NFL Draft pick. McMillan’s size, skill, and production scream long-term WR1 in fantasy football, and I compare him to Mike Evans—a dominant, reliable outside receiver. His positional value keeps him firmly in this tier.
Ashton Jeanty - 5’9”, 215 LBS (RB, Boise State)
Jeanty is a generational talent at running back and the likely 2024 Heisman Trophy winner. He’s the first RB since 2019 to surpass 2,000 rushing yards in a season and currently sits at 2,497 yards. Jeanty’s explosiveness was on full display with a 61-yard TD against Wyoming, and his consistent production has helped propel Boise State into College Football Playoff contention. With elite athleticism and vision, Jeanty’s skill set is perfectly suited for the NFL. His immediate fantasy upside should vault him into the Top 8 dynasty assets as soon as he’s drafted, making him a no-brainer in the top tier of this class.
These two players are not just the cream of the 2025 draft crop—they’re foundational pieces for dynasty managers. For me, though, I am drafting McMillan 1.01 right now just based on the lack of clear depth at the receiver position and just how loaded the running back class is. I feel like the production you could get from a running back at 2.01 could be close to Jeanty, while there is no one at the receiver position that will be sitting there that will be closed to McMillan.
Wide receivers are MHJ, Nabers, Drake London, Ladd, Hopkins and Ridley. Do you move any of them for a top running back? I already have Gibbs, Pacheco, and Tracy. And before you ask, I missed the damn playoffs this year. @realspencerg
If you’re missing the playoffs and looking to retool for next season, the two wide receivers I’d consider moving are Marvin Harrison Jr. or Calvin Ridley. Let’s break this down.
Marvin Harrison Jr.
I know trading a generational talent like MHJ might feel counterintuitive, but sometimes you have to make bold moves to address team needs. Harrison’s rookie season has been inconsistent, with an 11.5 PPG average and only six double-digit Fantasy performances over 13 weeks. Those big blow-up games (29 points in Week 2 and 23 in Week 8) skew his value higher than his week-to-week production has warranted.
The issue isn’t Harrison’s talent—it’s the team context. Protection issues limit his ability to connect on deep routes, and he’s become more of a decoy in the offense. That might change as the offense evolves, but if you can leverage Harrison’s name value for a top-tier running back like Jonathan Taylor or De’Von Achane, it’s worth exploring.
Example Dynasty Trades (12 Team SF/TE Premium):
Marvin Harrison Jr. for Jonathan Taylor
Marvin Harrison Jr. for De’Von Achane
Marvin Harrison Jr. for Tua Tagovailoa + Brian Robinson
Marvin Harrison Jr. for Jaxon Smith-Njigba + Chase Brown
Calvin Ridley
Ridley is another player I’d consider moving, especially for a running back who can stabilize your roster. Despite dealing with QB inconsistency, Ridley has maintained a solid target share and remains a volume-based option. In his best stretches, he’s shown WR1 upside with a 55.6-yard-per-game average and over a 25% target share in Tennessee’s offense. However, the inconsistency is frustrating, and selling him during the offseason might yield the best return.
Look for managers who are looking to buy low on Ridley, especially those optimistic about his situation improving next year with better quarterback play. A player like Travis Etienne is an ideal target if you’re looking for younger RBs with potential bounce-back value.
Example Dynasty Trades (12 Team SF/TE Premium):
Calvin Ridley for Travis Etienne
Calvin Ridley for D’Andre Swift
Calvin Ridley for J.K. Dobbins + 2025 2nd
Calvin Ridley for Tank Bigsby + 2025 3rd
Calvin Ridley for James Conner/2025 4th
Final Thoughts
I would try to sell Ridley before moving a player like Marvin Harrison Jr. But if I do move MHJ I want a top 5 running back asset in return.
Do you think Air Nolan stays in the BIG10 conference? @ThePPRShow
The simple answer? Maybe. Air Noland, a true freshman in 2024, didn’t see any playing time at Ohio State. He was buried on the depth chart as the fifth quarterback behind Will Howard, Devin Brown (who also hit the portal but is sticking around for the CFP), Julian Sayin, and Lincoln Kienholz.
Noland was a highly regarded prospect, a four-star recruit ranked No. 56 overall and the No. 4 quarterback in the 2024 class, per 247Sports Composite. At one point, he was viewed as Ohio State’s quarterback of the future, but with the arrival of Sayin—arguably the best QB in his class—Noland’s path to playing time became murky. Add to that Sayin's odds-on favorite status to start next year, and it’s not hard to see why Noland might explore other options.
Where Could He Land?
If Noland stays in the BIG10, Indiana stands out as an intriguing fit. Under Curt Cignetti, Indiana had a historic 2024 season, reaching 10 wins and nearly securing a spot in the expanded College Football Playoff. With Kurtis Rourke exhausting his eligibility, Indiana needs a new leader at QB.
Cignetti could look to Tyler Cherry, a freshman, or Tayven Jackson, who will be a junior next season, to take over. But if there’s a chance to snag someone like Noland and develop him into a solid starter, it’d be hard to pass up—especially with the added bonus of potentially sticking it to Ohio State in the process.
While Indiana has some young quarterbacks in the pipeline, Cignetti might avoid adding another young project through the portal. Still, the idea of Noland stepping into that role, continuing Indiana’s winning momentum, and sparking a rivalry with the Buckeyes? That’s a storyline I’d love to see unfold.
Fantasy Outlook
Even if Noland does end up at Indiana, he’s not someone I’m actively targeting in devy or C2C leagues. There are too many question marks around his development and potential to burn a roster spot on him right now.
In a 10 man SF, I want to add a 2nd flex position but should I put it to a vote? It’s a Home league, too, so not everyone is a dynasty nerd. @dynastydiddy
Since it’s a home league, I’d tread carefully with adding anything new unless there’s strong support across the board. Home leagues are all about having fun with friends/family and keeping everyone engaged. If adding a second flex spot feels like it might cause tension or disrupt the league’s vibe, it’s probably best to hold off. The last thing you want is to make changes that alienate more casual managers.
That said, if you’re looking to make a case for the second flex, it does have its perks. Adding another flex spot brings more strategy into play and keeps scoring exciting. It also helps balance roster depth, especially in leagues where talent tends to pile up on benches.
My advice? Be transparent with the league. Bring it up as a suggestion, explain the benefits, and then put it to a vote. Make it clear that the change only happens if there’s unanimous agreement. That way, everyone has a say, and you’re not forcing something on the league that some members might not want.
At the end of the day, the goal is to keep your league competitive while ensuring everyone enjoys the experience.