2024 Rookie Re-Draft (Dynasty Values, Dynasty Trades, Buys/Sells)

Kevin takes a look at how the 2024 class is currently being valued in mock draft form.

In dynasty leagues, the value of rookie picks can shift dramatically within just a few games, and the 2024 rookie class is no exception. As we head into the second half of the season, it’s time to reassess where this year’s rookies stand in terms of dynasty value. In our 2024 Rookie Re-Draft, we’ve pulled together insights from KeepTradeCut and FantasyCalc rankings to determine the top 36 rookie assets based on market trends. If you want to see the full market values, here is the link.

We’re diving into each first-round pick with a full breakdown of their current market value and some real trade data to guide your next moves. This isn’t just about who’s rising and falling; it’s about spotting the best buys and sells to keep you ahead in your league. Whether you’re ready to double down on a breakout talent, cash in on a player who’s peaking, or take a shot on an undervalued prospect, this re-draft will give you the edge you need in a constantly shifting dynasty market. Let’s get into it and see where these rookies stand now—and what moves make the most sense going forward.

1st Round Takeaways

Jayden Daniels' experience in college—a whopping 51 starts—is a big reason why he's now being viewed as high as QB1 in dynasty leagues. Unlike many rookies who come in with limited starting experience, Daniels had the chance to refine his game across multiple seasons, amassing elite numbers that highlight both his passing efficiency and dynamic rushing ability. With 12,750 passing yards, 89 touchdowns, 20 interceptions, and a passer rating of 158.4, along with over 3,300 rushing yards and 35 rushing touchdowns, Daniels brings the type of resume dynasty managers crave. And now, in the NFL, he’s showing why that college experience matters, sitting as QB3 overall and leading the Commanders to an unexpected winning record.

Looking ahead at the 2025 quarterback class and beyond, experience and starts should be a priority when evaluating incoming rookies. Studies have shown that quarterbacks with at least 20 starts in college generally transition better to the NFL. Since the 2008 draft, seven quarterbacks have been drafted in the first round with fewer than 20 collegiate starts. Those seven were:

• Trey Lance-17 Starts

• Mac Jones-17 Starts

• Kyler Murray-18 Starts

• Dwayne Haskins-14 Starts

• Mitch Trubisky- 13 Starts

• Ryan Tannehill-19 Starts

• Mark Sanchez-16 Starts

• Anthony Richardson-13 Starts

The exception? Kyler Murray, who managed to thrive despite his limited experience due to his elite athleticism and rushing ability. Anthony Richardson’s 13 college starts and subsequent early injury in his rookie season highlight the risks of low-experience QBs—especially for dynasty managers looking to invest heavily in their development. Daniels’ journey is a case study of how invaluable starts and experience can be in ensuring a quarterback’s success at the next level. It’s a trend to watch as we progress into the off-season and look at 2025 quarterbacks.